LiteratureReviewMatrixVIP专享VIP免费

LiteratureReviewMatrixTitle:Authors:J/C:DOI:Year:1)Readthetitle,abstract&introduction.2)Readthesub-headings.3)Readtheconclusion.4)Skimthereferencesforfamiliarones.1stPASS(5-10minutes)Category:Isthispaperuseful?Context:Correctness:Contributions:Clarity:1）readthepaperwithgreatercare,butignoredetails2）jotdownthekeypoints3）makecomments4）checkthefigures,diagramsandotherillustrations5）markrelevantunreadreferences2ndPASS(1+hour)WhatDoesitRationale:Aims:Hypothesis:HowDoesitDoit?Participants/Fundamentals:KernelPrinciples:Methods/Algorithms:Findings:Implications:Falsifiable:WhatDiditFind?Limitations:1)re-createtheworkthroughmakingthesameassumptionsastheauthors.2)identifyinnovationswithhiddenfailingsandassumptionsthroughcomparingourre-creationwiththeactualpaper3)thinkabouthowtopresentaparticularidea.3rdPASS(2+hours)WeaknessesPinpointImplicitAssumptions:Experimental/AnalyticalErrors:AlgorithmInsufficiency:MissingCitation:PresentationTechnique:SupportforConclusion:InternalEfficacy:StrenOurideasRe-created/GeneralizedAssumptions:Re-created/Principles:Novel/ModifiedAlgorithm:Novel/AmendedProof:HigherLevelConclusions: